Back to Resources
    Web Design
    Blog PostLast Updated: September 26, 2026

    What Questions Should I Ask a Web Design Agency Before Hiring? (Reddit Checklist + Red Flags)

    A practical 10-question checklist for comparing web design agencies, with the answers you should expect and the red flags Reddit users warn about.

    Quick Answer

    Before hiring a web design agency, ask whether you can see the site before paying, who owns it, whether SEO is included, examples of similar work, what happens if you're unhappy, timelines, maintenance, communication, how success is measured, and whether they use templates or custom design. Clear, specific answers signal a trustworthy agency.

    Questions to ask a web design agency before hiring

    Hiring a web design agency is a significant decision for a small business. The wrong choice can mean months of delays, a site you don't own, or a beautiful design that never brings in a single lead. This checklist is built from common Reddit discussions in r/smallbusiness, r/webdev and r/Entrepreneur, plus what we've seen from business owners who came to us after bad experiences elsewhere.

    What Reddit users warn about

    The horror stories repeat: agencies that hold domains hostage, disappear after launch, charge for every small change, or deliver templates sold as custom work. The most common advice is to get ownership and deliverables in writing, see real examples, and never pay 100% up front for work you haven't seen.

    The 10-question checklist

    Here's each question, why it matters, and how Cloud Peak Solutions answers it.

    1. Do you show me the site before I pay?

    Many agencies require large deposits before any design exists. At Cloud Peak Solutions, you see your site before you pay — removing most of the risk.

    2. Who owns the website?

    You should own your domain, content and site. Some agencies lease sites or keep domains in their accounts. With us, you own it.

    3. Is SEO included?

    A site without basic SEO is hard to find. We build local SEO into every site: page titles, structure, speed, schema and Google Business Profile integration.

    4. Can I see examples of similar businesses you've built for?

    Ask for live sites in your industry or a similar one. Our portfolio includes childcare centres, clinics, contractors and service businesses.

    5. What happens if I'm not happy?

    Look for a clear revision process. We revise until the site matches the agreed scope, and because you review before paying, you're never locked into something you dislike.

    6. How long does it take?

    Small business sites should typically take weeks, not months. We give a realistic timeline up front and keep you updated.

    7. Do you do ongoing maintenance?

    Sites need updates, backups and security monitoring. We offer website maintenance so your site stays fast, secure and current.

    8. What's your communication process?

    You should know who your contact is and how quickly they respond. We work directly with you, with a small accountable team.

    9. How do you measure success?

    The answer should be leads, calls and bookings — not just page views. We track form submissions, calls and Google profile actions.

    10. Do you use templates or custom design?

    Templates aren't bad if they're customized properly, but you should know what you're paying for. We design around your business, brand and customers.

    Red flags to watch for

    Walk away if you see these:

    • 100% payment up front before any design is shown.
    • Domain registered in the agency's name.
    • No live examples of previous work.
    • Vague answers about timelines or pricing.
    • Guaranteed number-one Google rankings.
    • Hidden fees for hosting, edits or access to your own site.
    • No plan for maintenance or support after launch.

    Additional questions worth asking

    Depending on your business, also ask about:

    • Accessibility compliance (especially AODA for Ontario businesses).
    • Privacy compliance under PIPEDA for forms.
    • Mobile speed and Core Web Vitals.
    • Who writes the copy and sources photos.
    • Integration with booking tools, CRMs or payment systems.

    Why these questions matter now

    Statistics show about 18% of local businesses in Canada still have no website, and Google reports that 46% of searches have local intent. A good website is increasingly the difference between being found and being skipped. AI Overviews, appearing in roughly 45% of searches, also reward well-structured sites — another reason to ask about SEO and structure up front.

    About Cloud Peak Solutions

    Cloud Peak Solutions is a Vancouver BC agency offering web design, local SEO, Google Business Profile management and website maintenance for small businesses across Canada and the US. We designed our process to pass every question on this list. For more guidance, read how to choose a web design agency in Canada.

    Get everything in writing

    Once you've chosen, confirm scope, price, timeline, revision rounds, ownership and maintenance terms in a written agreement before work begins. It protects both sides and prevents most disputes.

    Check reviews and references

    Look beyond testimonials the agency chooses to show. Read their Google reviews, check how they respond to criticism, and ask to speak with one or two past clients. Ask those clients whether the project finished on time, whether costs matched the quote and whether the agency still responds after launch. Five minutes on the phone with a past client often tells you more than an hour-long sales call.

    How to compare quotes side by side

    Agency quotes are notoriously hard to compare because each lists different things. Put them in a simple spreadsheet with the same rows for each: number of pages, copywriting included, SEO work included, Google Business Profile setup, hosting cost, maintenance cost, revision rounds, timeline, ownership terms and payment schedule. A cheaper quote that excludes copywriting, SEO and maintenance often ends up costing more once you add those back in.

    What good answers sound like

    Strong agencies answer specifically and in writing. Instead of “SEO is included,” you'll hear what's included — page titles, structured data, speed optimization, Google Business Profile integration. Instead of “we're fast,” you'll hear a timeline with milestones. Instead of “you'll love it,” you'll hear how revisions work and what happens if you don't. Vague, enthusiastic answers are a warning sign; precise, slightly boring answers usually mean the agency has done this many times.

    Questions for after launch

    Also ask what happens once the site is live:

    • Who handles updates, and how quickly?
    • How are backups and security handled?
    • Can I edit content myself if I want to?
    • What happens to my site if I stop paying for maintenance?

    Next step

    Bring this checklist to every agency you talk to — including us. Compare our packages or contact us and ask us all ten. Ready to grow your business online? Let's talk — Cloud Peak Solutions offers free strategy calls for small businesses across Canada and the US. Visit cloudpeak.solutions/contact

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is the most important question to ask a web designer?

    Who owns the website and domain. Without ownership, you risk losing your site or paying to get it back.

    Should I pay a web design agency up front?

    Avoid paying 100% before seeing work. Look for agencies that show designs before full payment or use milestone payments.

    Is SEO included in web design?

    It should be, at least the fundamentals. Always ask what SEO work is included and get it in writing.

    How long should a small business website take?

    Most small business websites take a few weeks, depending on content and revisions. Be cautious of vague timelines.

    What are red flags when hiring a web design agency?

    Full payment up front, no live examples, agency-owned domains, guaranteed rankings and no post-launch support plan.

    About the Author

    This article was written by the team at Cloud Peak Solutions, a Vancouver-based web design and digital marketing agency helping small businesses across Canada and the US get more customers online through professional web design, local SEO, and Google Business Profile management. Learn more at cloudpeak.solutions.

    Related articles

    Ready to grow your business online? Let's talk.

    Cloud Peak Solutions offers free strategy calls for small businesses across Canada and the US.

    Contact Us