What Portfolio Should I Look for When Hiring a Designer? (Reddit Tips + What Actually Matters)
Reddit threads are full of advice on vetting web designer portfolios. Here's what actually matters beyond pretty screenshots — live sites, results, and process.
Head into r/web_design, r/smallbusiness, or r/Entrepreneur and you'll find the same thread posted every week: 'How do I tell if a designer's portfolio is actually good?' The reason it never goes away is that most portfolios are optimized to impress other designers, not to help a business owner decide who can actually ship a site that earns money. Awards, dribbble-style mockups, and moody hero shots don't tell you whether the designer can launch a fast, findable, conversion-focused site for a real client.
Why Reddit keeps having this conversation
Head into r/web_design, r/smallbusiness, or r/Entrepreneur and you'll find the same thread posted every week: 'How do I tell if a designer's portfolio is actually good?' The reason it never goes away is that most portfolios are optimized to impress other designers, not to help a business owner decide who can actually ship a site that earns money. Awards, dribbble-style mockups, and moody hero shots don't tell you whether the designer can launch a fast, findable, conversion-focused site for a real client.
What the best Reddit threads agree on
The advice that consistently gets upvoted is boringly practical: click every project link and load it on your phone, see if the site is still live, check page speed, look at whether visitors can actually contact the business, and read the case study for real numbers — not vibes. If a portfolio is 100% mockups with no live URLs, that's the single biggest red flag. Our own portfolio links to real, launched Canadian small-business sites so you can do exactly this kind of check.
The signals that actually predict a good outcome
Diversity of industries (proves they can learn a business, not just repeat one template), consistent conversion patterns across projects, mobile-first layouts that don't fall apart under 400px, and case studies that mention goals, constraints, and measurable outcomes. Bonus points if the designer shows before/afters or references. See How Do I Know If a Web Designer Is Qualified? for the deeper qualification checklist.
Red flags Reddit repeats over and over
Stock-heavy hero images with no real content, identical layouts across five 'different' clients, no phone numbers or contact info on the client sites (a sign the designer didn't think about leads), broken links in the portfolio itself, and vague copy like 'increased engagement by 200%' with no baseline. Also watch for portfolios that only show desktop screenshots — over 60% of small-business traffic is mobile, and hiding phone views usually means the mobile version is rough.
Questions to bring to your first call
Ask which project they're most proud of and why, what they'd change about it now, who wrote the copy, how long the site took, and what the client's goal was. A designer who can answer those clearly is worth talking to. One who deflects is not. If you want a template for the whole conversation, see How Do I Brief a Web Designer on My Project?.
Your next step
Compare a few designers using the criteria above. If you want to see how we stack up, browse our portfolio, review packages, or contact us for a free 20-minute portfolio review where we'll walk through what to look for in any designer you're considering — even if it's not us.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a professional small business website cost in Canada?
Most small business websites in Canada cost between $1,500 and $8,000 for a one-time build, or $23–$95 per month on a managed plan. See our current packages for exact pricing.
How long does it take to build a new website?
A typical small business website takes 2–4 weeks from kickoff to launch. Larger custom builds with e-commerce or booking systems usually take 4–8 weeks.
Do you handle hosting and ongoing maintenance?
Yes. Every Cloud Peak Solutions plan includes hosting, SSL, backups, security updates, and monthly content edits so your site stays fast and secure.
About the Author
This article was written by the team at Cloud Peak Solutions, a Vancouver-based web design and digital marketing agency helping small businesses across Canada and the US get more customers online through professional web design, local SEO, and Google Business Profile management. Learn more at cloudpeak.solutions.
Related articles
Ready to grow your business online? Let's talk.
Cloud Peak Solutions offers free strategy calls for small businesses across Canada and the US.
Contact Us